Community

Bay Harbor

Fleming Island, Clay County, FL

Overview

Community Information

This is the official information hub for Bay Harbor. Below you'll find recorded covenants and restrictions, plats, and current board officers.

Homes & Addresses
53 home(s)
Documents & Records
1 item(s)
Board Officers
3 listed
Amenities
2 feature(s)
How It Works
The brokerage built for your community

Lifestyle

Community Amenities

Shared amenities in Bay Harbor, compiled from recent MLS listings. Amenities can change over time — confirm with the association.

Basketball Court
Playground

Location

Map of Bay Harbor

Bay Harbor is in Fleming Island, Clay County, Florida. Each pin is one of the 53 homes on record — select a pin to open that property's page.

Parcel locations from the county property appraiser. Boundaries are approximate — confirm any lot line with the recorded plat. See all communities on one map →

Schools

Schools Zoned for Bay Harbor

Bay Harbor straddles more than one attendance boundary — the homes are split between the schools below.

Fleming Island Elementary School Elementary · 39 homes
Swimming Pen Creek Elementary School Elementary · 14 homes
Lakeside Junior High School Middle
Fleming Island High School High

Zoned public schools from county attendance boundaries — magnet and school-choice options may also apply, and boundaries are redrawn periodically. Confirm enrollment with the school district.

Public Records

Is Bay Harbor Safe? Crime Reports Near Bay Harbor

The HOA Collective does not rate neighborhoods and does not publish a safety score. Bay Harbor is in Clay County, and the Clay County Sheriff's Office does not publish an open incident dataset, so we publish no incident counts here. Reported incidents for this area can be looked up directly at the sources below.

Management

Community Management

No professional management company is on file with the state for this community. See the Board Officers below.

On the Market

Homes for Sale in Bay Harbor

Active MLS listings in this community. Thinking of selling? List with us →

For Sale ↓ $15,000
$369,900 $384,900
2329 SIDE WHEEL Court
4 bd · 2 ba
Courtesy of NEXTHOME COLLINS REALTY

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) program of the Northeast Florida Multiple Listing Service, Inc. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than The HOA Collective LLC are marked with the listing broker's name and detailed information about such listings includes the name of the listing brokers. Data provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed. © 2026 Northeast Florida Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved.

Homes

Homes & Addresses

All 53 homes in Bay Harbor. Search an address to open its property details, valuation, and sale history.

1500 BAY HARBOR Dr 1,766 sqft · Built 2001 1503 BAY HARBOR Dr 1,885 sqft · Built 2001 1504 BAY HARBOR Dr 2,087 sqft · Built 2001 1507 BAY HARBOR Dr 2,188 sqft · Built 2001 1508 BAY HARBOR Dr 2,610 sqft · Built 2002 1512 BAY HARBOR Dr 2,189 sqft · Built 2001 1518 BAY HARBOR Dr 1,835 sqft · Built 2002 1522 BAY HARBOR Dr 2,197 sqft · Built 2001 1526 BAY HARBOR Dr 1,764 sqft · Built 2002 1530 BAY HARBOR Dr 2,408 sqft · Built 2002 1534 BAY HARBOR Dr 1,561 sqft · Built 2002 1538 BAY HARBOR Dr 1,884 sqft · Built 2002 1542 BAY HARBOR Dr 1,598 sqft · Built 2002 1546 BAY HARBOR Dr 1,937 sqft · Built 2001 1547 BAY HARBOR Dr 1,660 sqft · Built 2002 1550 BAY HARBOR Dr 1,768 sqft · Built 2002 1556 BAY HARBOR Dr 1,937 sqft · Built 2002 1563 BAY HARBOR Dr 1,573 sqft · Built 2002 1567 BAY HARBOR Dr 2,069 sqft · Built 2001 1571 BAY HARBOR Dr 1,753 sqft · Built 2002 1575 BAY HARBOR Dr 1,937 sqft · Built 2001 1579 BAY HARBOR Dr 1,596 sqft · Built 2002 1583 BAY HARBOR Dr 2,269 sqft · Built 2000 1587 BAY HARBOR Dr 1,574 sqft · Built 2002 1591 BAY HARBOR Dr 1,926 sqft · Built 2003 1595 BAY HARBOR Dr 2,496 sqft · Built 2000 1599 BAY HARBOR Dr 2,468 sqft · Built 2002 2300 RIVER BOAT Ct 2,052 sqft · Built 2001 2303 RIVER BOAT Ct 2,697 sqft · Built 2002 2304 RIVER BOAT Ct 2,237 sqft · Built 2001 2307 RIVER BOAT Ct 2,283 sqft · Built 2002 2311 RIVER BOAT Ct 2,697 sqft · Built 2002 2314 RIVER BOAT Ct 1,722 sqft · Built 2002 2315 RIVER BOAT Ct 1,783 sqft · Built 2001 2319 RIVER BOAT Ct 2,517 sqft · Built 2001 2320 RIVER BOAT Ct 1,925 sqft · Built 2001 2322 SIDE WHEEL Ct 1,542 sqft · Built 2001 2325 SIDE WHEEL Ct 2,113 sqft · Built 2002 2326 SIDE WHEEL Ct 1,955 sqft · Built 2002 2329 SIDE WHEEL Ct 1,740 sqft · Built 2001 2330 SIDE WHEEL Ct 1,802 sqft · Built 2002 2333 SIDE WHEEL Ct 1,797 sqft · Built 2002 2335 SIDE WHEEL Ct 1,992 sqft · Built 2001 2336 SIDE WHEEL Ct 2,297 sqft · Built 2001 2339 SIDE WHEEL Ct 1,897 sqft · Built 2001 2340 SIDE WHEEL Ct 1,784 sqft · Built 2001 2342 STERNWHEEL Ct 2,057 sqft · Built 2001 2345 STERNWHEEL Ct 2,555 sqft · Built 2001 2346 STERNWHEEL Ct 2,335 sqft · Built 2001 2349 STERNWHEEL Ct 1,965 sqft · Built 2001 2350 STERNWHEEL Ct 2,237 sqft · Built 2001 2353 STERNWHEEL Ct 1,554 sqft · Built 2002 2357 STERNWHEEL Ct 1,574 sqft · Built 2002

Rules & Records

Bay Harbor HOA Rules, Covenants & Documents

The rules for Bay Harbor are laid out in its recorded covenants and restrictions — the CC&Rs, their amendments, and the bylaws. Below are the copies we have on file, free to read or download.

Covenants & Restrictions

Declaration of Covenants, Conditions & Restrictions — O 1872/0399

Book/Page: O 1872/0399 Recorded: 2000-07-07

View document →

Leadership

Board Officers

President / Secretary
Batchelder Richard
Vice President / President
Harley Melanie
Secretary / Chairman
Yelverton Paul
Bryce Spraggins, Jacksonville Realtor and licensed Florida real estate broker

List With Me

Selling in Bay Harbor? List with the Realtor built for your community.

I'm Bryce Spraggins, a Jacksonville REALTOR® and licensed Florida real estate broker — and The HOA Collective works Bay Harbor every day. We know your covenants, your comps, and what buyers ask about your neighborhood before they ever tour it.

904-747-1HOAcall or text bryce@thehoacollective.com
Got it — thank you. I'll reach out shortly at the number you gave. If it's urgent, call or text 904-747-1HOA.
See the receipts — why homeowners list with us →

Our sister company

Don't want to list? Get a cash offer from My Fair Market Offer.

My Fair Market Offer is our sister company and a direct cash home buyer in Jacksonville and NE Florida. Sell as-is with no repairs, no showings and no commission — useful if you need to close on a date certain. Same owner, same phone, no obligation either way.

Get a Cash Offer myfairmarketoffer.com

Questions & Answers

Frequently Asked

What county is Bay Harbor in?
Bay Harbor is an HOA community in Clay County, Florida, with 53 homes.
What is the HOA fee in Bay Harbor?
The HOA fee in Bay Harbor is approximately $300 per year, based on recent MLS listings. Dues can vary by lot — confirm with the association.
Where can I find Bay Harbor's CC&Rs and HOA documents?
Recorded governing documents for Bay Harbor — CC&Rs, amendments, and plats — are published by The HOA Collective and available in the Documents & Records section of the Bay Harbor community page at thehoacollective.com/communities/bay-harbor-3.
Are there homes for sale in Bay Harbor?
Yes — there is 1 active listing in Bay Harbor. Current prices and details are on the Bay Harbor community page at thehoacollective.com/communities/bay-harbor-3.
What amenities does Bay Harbor have?
Bay Harbor offers shared community amenities including basketball court and playground, based on recent MLS listings. Amenities can change — confirm current offerings with the association.
Does Bay Harbor have a pool?
No community pool is listed among Bay Harbor's shared amenities in recent MLS listings. Individual homes may still have private pools. Confirm current amenities with the association.
What schools are zoned for Bay Harbor?
Homes in Bay Harbor are zoned for elementary: Fleming Island Elementary School (39 homes) and Swimming Pen Creek Elementary School (14 homes); middle: Lakeside Junior High School; high: Fleming Island High School. Bay Harbor straddles more than one attendance boundary, so zoning varies by address. Zoning comes from county attendance boundaries and is redrawn periodically — per-address zoning is listed on each property page at thehoacollective.com/communities/bay-harbor-3.
What are the HOA rules in Bay Harbor?
The rules for Bay Harbor are set out in its recorded covenants and restrictions (CC&Rs), along with any amendments and the bylaws — these cover things like fences, parking, exterior changes and rentals. The copies on file are free to read in the Rules & Records section of the Bay Harbor community page at thehoacollective.com/communities/bay-harbor-3.
How much are property taxes in Bay Harbor?
The median property-tax bill in Bay Harbor is about $2,807 for 2025, based on 52 homes on the county tax roll. Most homes fall between $2,007 and $4,656. Your bill depends on assessed value and exemptions — homesteaded owners typically pay less.
When was Bay Harbor built?
Most homes in Bay Harbor were built between 2001 and 2002, with the typical home dating to 2001, according to county property records. The oldest home on record dates to 2000.
Where is Bay Harbor?
Bay Harbor is in Fleming Island, Clay County, Florida. It has 53 homes on record. An interactive map showing every home in the community is on the Bay Harbor community page at thehoacollective.com/communities/bay-harbor-3.
Where can I look up crime reports near Bay Harbor?
Bay Harbor is in Clay County, Florida. The Clay County Sheriff's Office does not publish an open incident dataset, so The HOA Collective publishes no incident counts for Bay Harbor. Links to the agency's own records, and to any map it contributes to, are published on the Bay Harbor community page at thehoacollective.com/communities/bay-harbor-3.