Lake Cunningham at Cunningham Creek Plantation

269 N LAKE CUNNINGHAM AVE

Saint Johns, FL 32259
Sold · Aug 2025 $485,000
4 bd · 3 ba · Built 2001
Bryce Spraggins — The HOA Collective
Schedule a Showing with Bryce

See this home in person — Bryce Spraggins, The HOA Collective.

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) program of the Northeast Florida Multiple Listing Service, Inc. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than The HOA Collective LLC are marked with the listing broker's name and detailed information about such listings includes the name of the listing brokers. Data provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed.

Listing courtesy of TATUM REALTY AND PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SERVICES (cjhaackrealtor@gmail.com). Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Data from realMLS (Northeast Florida MLS). © 2026 Northeast Florida Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved.

About This Home

Taking back up offers. This beautifully maintained 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home in Lake Cunningham of Cunningham Creek Plantation offers 2,202 sq. ft. of living space, ideal for families or entertaining. Inside, you'll find a spacious formal dining room, a cozy family room with a fireplace, and a bright breakfast nook. The open kitchen allows for seamless interaction while cooking, and a front office provides a quiet workspace. The luxurious primary suite includes an oversized soaking tub, separate shower, and dual sinks. Enjoy serene lake views from the Florida room and the beautifully landscaped, fenced backyard, complete with a paver patio and firepit. Cunningham Creek Plantation amenities include a pool, playground, and soccer field. Located in St. Johns County, it's close to top-rated schools, shopping, and dining. Don't miss your chance to own this gem in a highly desirable neighborhood!

Property Details

Home Facts

TypeSingle Family
Year built2001
SubdivisionLake Cunningham at Cunningham Creek Plantation
Parcel (RE#)009777 0640
Legal description38/72-79 LAKE CUNNINGHAM AT CUNNINGHAM CREEK PLANTATION UNIT 2 LOT 64 OR6209/96

Valuation · 2025

Value

Just / Market
$485,000
Assessed
$288,858
Taxable
$238,136
2025 Property Tax
$3,367
Homestead Exemption
Yes $50,000 exempt

Estimated 2025 ad-valorem property tax (County taxable value × millage); excludes non-ad-valorem assessments. Homestead status per the County tax roll.

HOA Dues
$568 / Annually
CDD Assessment

HOA dues & CDD assessments are community-level (source: MLS). Confirm current amounts with the association or management.

History

Sale History

DatePriceDeed
2001-04-27

Location

Map

How far to
Open in Google Maps →

Utilities

Service Providers

⚡ Electric
JEA
💧 Water
JEA
🚽 Sewer
JEA

Providers serving this area — please confirm service directly with the provider.

Schools

Assigned & Nearby Schools

Nearby Private Schools

Zoned public schools from Duval County Public Schools attendance boundaries — magnet/choice options may also apply. Confirm enrollment with the school district.

Bryce Spraggins, Licensed Real Estate Broker

List With Me

Selling in Lake Cunningham at Cunningham Creek Plantation? List with the broker built for your community.

I'm Bryce Spraggins, a licensed Florida real estate broker — and The HOA Collective works Lake Cunningham at Cunningham Creek Plantation every day. We're on a mission to make community management more affordable: every home we sell helps fund reduced-cost management software and services for HOAs through MyHOAClub.

Questions & Answers

Frequently Asked

What schools serve 269 N LAKE CUNNINGHAM AVE?
The zoned public schools for 269 N LAKE CUNNINGHAM AVE in Lake Cunningham at Cunningham Creek Plantation are Cunningham Creek Elementary School (elementary), Fruit Cove Middle School (middle), Bartram Trail High School (high). Magnet and choice options may also apply — confirm enrollment with the district.
What are the property taxes on 269 N LAKE CUNNINGHAM AVE?
The most recent annual property tax for 269 N LAKE CUNNINGHAM AVE is about $3,367 (2025 tax year), with a homestead exemption applied. Any CDD assessment is billed in addition.
What is the HOA fee for 269 N LAKE CUNNINGHAM AVE?
Homes in Lake Cunningham at Cunningham Creek Plantation have an HOA fee of about $568 per year (based on recent MLS listings).

Property data is sourced from the St. Johns County Property Appraiser public records (view official record →). Values are appraiser estimates and may not reflect market price.